[nerdjon]

I strongly disagree.

I often have apps on my Mac or iPhone that ask for permission to see my camera, microphone, contacts, etc etc that I don't want it to see. But I do want other apps to be able to access those things.

Being able to stop those apps from accessing before they do instead of trying to fix it after is incredibly valuable.

Sure some users just accept everything, but that is not an argument against them existing in the first place.

[alpaca128]

Those examples are very reasonable. However I also had Mac OS suddenly treat all m4a files on the system as potential malware and it blocked any attempt at opening them. Why did it do that? Because I checked the "set as default app" option, one minute after I had already opened the same file using the same application. The only way to open the files was by entering the password in the settings app each time - but re-setting the same app as default in the file's Get Info dialog got rid of that "protection" system-wide without any password prompts or extra permissions. I don't see how that was supposed to help with security.

[StilesCrisis]

I am pretty sure you're running into a bug and trying to make sense of a behavior that wasn't intended to exist.

[alpaca128]

This has been a thing long enough for online guides to exist that explain how to get rid of it. Fortunately, because setting the default program in a second place to get rid of a security barrier wasn't my first guess. When does a bug start to become an undocumented feature?

[StilesCrisis]

This certainly isn't the only Mac bug that would be old enough to drive.