Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Etheryte 69 days ago
The truth is most apps have no business having a menubar icon, but many of them cannot even be disabled out of the box. There's a number of third-party tools that help with the issue, but really this should be handled at the OS level. I want a permission similar to notifications to control whether an app can litter the menubar or not.
2 comments

One thing's for sure: No application should be allowed to have a menubar item without a ToolTip. WTF, that should have been obvious from day one.

At the moment, I have 11 of them on my system (not counting the clock), a mix of third-party and Apple ones. NOT ONE of them has a ToolTip.

Even worse, if you click on them, the resulting menu does not show the name of the owning application. This too should be forced. For example, I unfortunately have to run Microsoft Teams, and its toolbar menu gives you no indication of what application it belongs to.

It is in Tahoe, which is on the short list of things I strongly, genuinely like about the update.
Thank you! I did not know about this change, even though I already am on Tahoe. Much appreciated.
You’re welcome! I stumbled across that myself. It wasn’t exactly a premier feature, yet still one of my favorites.