Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tptacek 79 days ago
At the point where you're implying that a submarine is compelled to surface, you've departed any recognizable modern law of naval warfare.
1 comments

Per the GP:

> Legally, there's much here that's hard to pin down, massive grey areas and a lot of jelly to nail to the wall.

Similar to an earlier comment you made to me, what references do you have that say that GCII Article 18 is 100% not applicable to submarines? Or more broadly that support your assertion that "you've departed any recognizable modern law of naval warfare."