Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lostlogin 77 days ago
> What do you think the US government expected from this?

That they’d beat Iran and have some friendly dictator installed in short order.

Are you arguing that this is going how the US planned?

When was the last time the US had this much trouble getting its allies to follow it into war?

1 comments

I think civil servants and military planners in the US were aware of the threat of a global oil shock if Iran closed the Strait of Hormuz. This is a well-known enough scenario that the Battlefield games have maps on Kharg Island. Everyone knows it's Iran's greatest leverage. They even threaten to close the Strait regularly.

The administration would have been informed of the risks to the US, which are relatively minor in comparison since the US is a net exporter of crude, and ignored them. If the risks had been greater, they would not have ignored them, and would have at least had an actual plan to keep the Strait open. They might even have informed their close military allies using something other than Truth Social.

I am not arguing that they planned this, even though it should have been obvious that it would happen. I absolutely do believe they were warned it was a possibility and didn't care.