Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hiddew 85 days ago
For large applications, having the implementation (or multiple implementations) of certain functionality decoupled from the code using it, improves maintainability and configurability of the application. That is where inversion of control helps. And then manually writing the instatiation, scoping, dependency ordering and cleanup code to manage all of that is not useful to write yourself. Any dependency injection framework will work, although Spring is well used and has many integrations.
1 comments

Yeah, I get the idea, abstractions allow decoupling. But, think that it should be used in a thoughtful way - there is quote from the original Design Patterns book that said something like a careful considered use of Design Patterns should make the system easier to work with, or something like that (sorry, don't have it on hand).

We can go back and forth on this, so will just say, in my opinion, Spring autowiring overall doesn't provide enough benefit versus its downsides, which to me are: increased complexity and doesn't work well enough (it should be easier to debug autowiring problems for one).

You seem very knowledgeable about design, and, of course, you're entitled to your opinion, so seems like we'll probably just have to disagree on this:)