Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nightpool 85 days ago
Okay, but this contradicts your original statement that "Java doesn't steer anyone to use these [footguns]". Every language has a way to parse integers, and most developers do not need a custom parser. Only in Java does that suddenly become a performance footgun.
1 comments
ivan_gammel 85 days ago
It does not. If you need to parse a number, you use standard library and you will be fine. The described case with huge impact on hot path is the demonstration why using brains is important. The developer that will get into this mess is the one who will find the way to suffocate his code with performance bottlenecks in thousand other ways. It’s not a language or library problem.
link
dionian 85 days ago
Yes, parseInt et al work very fast for good inputs. What percentage of your inputs are invalid numbers and why ?
link
ivan_gammel 85 days ago
> What percentage of your inputs are invalid numbers and why ?

This is a wrong question to ask in this context. The right question to ask is when actually exceptional flow becomes a performance bottleneck. Because, obviously, in a desktop or even in a server app validating single user input even 99% of wrong inputs won’t cause any trouble. It may become a problem with bulk processing, but then, and I have to repeat myself here, it is no longer a number parsing problem, it’s a problem of not understanding what your input is.

link