[signal11]

I was using poetry pretty happily before uv came along. I’d probably go back.

Note that uv is fast because — yes, Rust, but also because it doesn’t have to handle a lot of legacy that pip does[1], and some smart language independent design choices.

If uv became unavailable, it’d suck but the world would move on.

[1] https://nesbitt.io/2025/12/26/how-uv-got-so-fast.html

[theLiminator]

Maybe I could give up uv, but giving up ruff would suck.

[crdrost]

This is just the weirdest thread.

Like, the whole point of open source is that this thread is not a thing. The whole point is "if this software is taken on by a malevolent dictator for life, we'll just fork it and keep going with our own thing." Or like if I'm evaluating whether to open-source stuff at a startup, the question is "if this startup fails to get funding and we have to close up shop, do I want the team to still have access to these tools at my next gig?" -- there are other reasons it might be in the company's interests, like getting free feature development or hiring better devs, but that's the main reason it'd be in the employees' best interests to want to contribute to an open-source legacy rather than keep everything proprietary.

[asa400]

The leadership and product direction work are at least as hard as the code work. Astral/uv has absolutely proven this, otherwise Python wouldn't be a boneyard for build tools.

Projects - including forks - fail all the time because the leadership/product direction on a project goes missing despite the tech still being viable, which is why people are concerned about these people being locked up inside OpenAI. Successfully forking is much easier said than done.

[PaulHoule]

I had a lot of trouble convincing people that a correct Python package manager was even possible. uv proved it was possible and won people over with speed.

I had a sketched out design for a correct package manager in 2018 but when I talked to people about it I couldn't get any interest in it. I think the brilliant idea that uv had that I missed was that it can't be written in Python because if is written in Python developers are going to corrupt its environment sooner or later and you lose your correctness.

I think that now that people are used to uv it won't be that hard to develop a competitor and get people to switch.