[jameswyse]

http://www.eachdayisagift.com/ looks like the one, but if it's not I also found these:

https://www.mysterygiftmachine.com/ http://www.ifting.com/ http://www.GiftLizard.com

btw: the search box at the bottom of the page works pretty well :)

[autonoms]

the first one is it! Thank you so so much! I tried hnsearch, but I guess I didn't have the right terms. Thank you!