[tptacek]

Wait, this comment starts out with an assertion about one scientific question (the construct validity of a quantitative psychological metric) and ends with a statement about the range of a totally different question, and it's one studied by different fields than the former question.

[xyzzyz]

Yes, I could have left off the last comment. I added it to illustrate where the debate currently lies. I am not sure what your point is.

[tptacek]

That the logic of your comment doesn't even hang together? Which debate? You've managed to cite two of them.

[xyzzyz]

I’m really struggling to understand what your point is. The person I replied to was wrong as to where the current debate is among experts, so I pointed it out, and gave an example of where the debate currently is. Is that really so strange thing to say?