[coderenegade]

There needs to be a measure (or measures) of the entropy of a codebase that provides a signal of complexity. When you're paying for every token, you want code patterns that convey a lot of immediate information to the agent so that it can either repeat the pattern, or extend it in a way that makes sense. This is probably the next wave of assisted coding (imo), because we're at the stage where writing code works, the quality is mostly decent, but it can be needlessly complex given the context of the existing repo.

[js8]

There's a way to measure "entropy" of a codebase. Take something like the binary lambda calculus or the triage calculus, convert your program (including libraries, programming language constructs, operating system) into it, and measure the size of the program in it in bits.

You can also measure the crossentropy, which is essentially the whole program entropy above minus entropy of the programming language and functions from standard libraries (i.e. abstractions that you assume are generally known). This is useful to evaluate the conformance to "standard" abstractions.

There is also a way to measure a "maximum entropy" using types, by counting number of states a data type can represent. The maximum entropy of a function is a crossentropy between inputs and outputs (treating the function like a communication channel).

The "difference" (I am not sure how to make them convertible) between "maximum entropy" and "function entropy" (size in bits) then shows how good your understanding (compared to specification expressed in type signature) of the function is.

I have been advocating for some time that we use entropy measures (and information theory) in SW engineering to do estimation of complexity (and thus time required for a change).

[malfist]

Maybe cyclomatic complexity would be a good proxy. It can obviously be gamed but it's obvious when it is

[johncomposed]

There was a measure used during the Toyota Unintended Acceleration case called McCabe Cyclomatic Complexity, I wonder if anyone is using it alongside AI assisted code.

[kqr]

It is roughly equivalent to diff size: https://entropicthoughts.com/lines-of-code

[bandrami]

I mean, it's ultimately a string, and the measurement of the entropy of a string is well-studied. The LLM might start gaming that with variable names so you'd need to do the AST instead. I may actually try something like that; cool idea.