Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Muhammad523 108 days ago
Novel programming languages have still educational value for those building them and, yes, we still need programming languages. I dont see any reason we would not need them. Even if Ai is going to write the code for you; how is it going to write it with no programming language? With raw binary? Absolutly not.
2 comments
cv5005 108 days ago
Eventually it wont need to write any code at all. The end goal for AI is "The Final Software" - no more software needs to be written, you just tell the AI what you actually want done and it does it, no need for it to generate a program.
link
ModernMech 108 days ago
But how do you know AI can generate programs without writing code? It can't today -- in fact the best thinking models work by writing code as part of the process. Natural intelligence requires it as well, as all our jobs are about expressing problem domains formally. So why would we expect an artificial intelligence should be able to reason about the kinds of programming problems we want them to without a formal language?

Maybe they will not be called programming languages anymore because that name was mostly incidental to the fact they were used to write programs. But formal, constructed languages are very much still needed because without them, you will struggle with abstraction, specification, setting constraints and boundaries, etc. if all you use is natural language. We invented these things for a reason!

Also the AI will have to communicate output to you, and you'll have to be sure of what it means, which is hard to do with natural language. Thus you'll still have to know how to read some form of code -- unless you're willing to be fooled by the AI through its imprecise use of natural language.

link
synergy20 108 days ago
how did you get that 'no programming language' conclusion? there are so many well established languages that are more than we need already, the market has picked the winners too, and AI has well trained with them, these are facts. If there is a new language needed down the road for AI coders, most likely it will be created by using AI itself. for the moment, human created niche language is too late for the party, move on.
link