Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hedgehog 105 days ago
Minisforum MS-S1 is the same chip but has a PCIe slot suitable for a network card.
3 comments

The Framework Desktop motherboard does actually have a PCIe x4 slot, their case just doesn't expose it for whatever reason. But you can buy the board separately and put it in your own choice of Mini-ITX case which does.
This case is cute and well built but it does have strange quirks, see also the noisy PSU [1]

[1] https://community.frame.work/t/noisy-psu-fan/74751

First I've heard of this thread (I haven't spent much time on the forums for a while), but my Framework Desktop definitely has the PSU noise issue, and it doesn't seem correlated to system load. Otherwise a really solid machine.
That PCI slot has low power output, not suitable for what people would plug into it. Easier to cover it than run into support problems. It won't run a GPU directly. It will run an Oculink card which will allow use of an egpu.
I can't imagine why you'd want to buy a beefy SOC with unified memory, only to have it host a discrete GPU through it's narrow PCIe x4 interface. You'd be better off with a traditional CPU that supports a proper x16 slot.
If you want to try both "Team Red" and "Team Green" stuff without having 2 hosts to manage, the x4 interface is a reasonable tradeoff.
I saw that, it's pretty strange.
In their article, AMD chose to use the built-in 5Gbe NIC, but I read you could use the two USB4 @40Gbps ports as interconnects too (or for USB NICs).
Or a Beelink GTR9 Pro with same chip and memory, and two 10GbE LAN ports built in for clustering several together.
The MS-S1 also has 2x 10Gb Ethernet, the value of the slot is going to a card with more bandwidth + RDMA support.
You need five network cards per node to make proper hypercube. Don't settle for less!
A really good switch will do, too.