Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bdangubic 105 days ago
E-Bikes and E-scooters and bunch of other modes of transportation have been recent addition and not only are they allowed (specifically E-Bikes) but you don’t need a license, they do not have to be registered and some can haul serious ass
1 comments
ryandrake 105 days ago
The difference being that only one of those things routinely kills people.
link
roenxi 105 days ago
E-bikes and e-scooters kill people daily, accidents on those things can mess people up and there are none of the safety mechanisms like crumple zones or seatbelts on a bike. If you search "e-bike deaths" you'll get hits.
link
ryandrake 105 days ago
Do they kill over a million people a year worldwide? How many orders of magnitude fewer people are killed by E-things?

OP's point was that if you invented something today that killed over a million people per year, it probably wouldn't be allowed, and I don't think that's really that controversial a statement.

link
roenxi 104 days ago
> Do they kill over a million people a year worldwide? How many orders of magnitude fewer people are killed by E-things?

On a per meter basis I'd expect bikes to be much worse. I've had more injuries on bike than in car, and people can certainly kill themselves on a bike. The main reason they don't is because the bad bike riders usually have enough accidents that they stop getting on the things. Bikes in themselves would probably be borderline illegal to sell if they were invented today, they don't look safe at all. And E-things are less safe again than ordinary bikes.

> OP's point was that if you invented something today that killed over a million people per year, it probably wouldn't be allowed, and I don't think that's really that controversial a statement.

I'm not replying to OP. I agree with him on this one and note that the implication of that is e-bikes are probably on their way towards being banned or restricted.

link
bdangubic 105 days ago
when the first cars started rolling down the streets they weren’t killing millions of people either
link
intended 105 days ago
Horse driven carriages also routinely killed people.

Humanity has always needed transport.

link