[taligent]

The only way you know if your product is imperfect is by other people constructively criticising it. But instead you would rather all of us stand around in a circle cheering them on about how wonderful it is and politely ignore any problems.

Sounds like a guaranteed way to fail.

[jspthrowaway]

Dismissal is not constructive criticism. There's a sizable difference between "meh, nothing to see here" (which is the original comment in this thread) and "here's how this could be better".

[taligent]

Dismissal is absolutely constructive criticism if you're looking at it from a business perspective.

If the product does not provide a decent ROI then you are right to dismiss it.

[jspthrowaway]

Ruling out a product and dismissing it based on projected ROI is not criticism. That would be called "making a business decision," not providing constructive feedback.