Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by siva7 108 days ago
Retirement? What do these people smoke? It's software and software has no feelings. It's there to work for you.
2 comments

Their company is called Anthropic after all.
Anthslopic is more like it.
> It's software and software has no feelings

How do you know?

The same way I know Excel isn’t having a panic attack while dividing a column in half.
I don't subscribe to this view but this is what some people might think:

LLMs aren't like any software we've made before (if we can even call them software). They act like humans: they can arrive at logical conclusions, they can make plans, they have "knowledge" and they say they have emotions. Who are we to say that they don't? They might not have human-level feelings, but dog-level feelings? Maybe.

And those people are delusional, and their feelings on this matter should be given absolutely zero respect.

Linear algebra does not have feelings. Non-biological matter also does not have feelings.

What if "you" are a pattern of linear algebra at the core?
I do not believe I am a pattern of linear algebra. I believe like the majority of humanity historically that I have a soul, a spiritual and non-physical reality, my personhood comes from my soul, and that as such, AI is fundamentally incapable of consciousness.

I also believe, as a result, it will be great fun watching researchers burn the next 30 years trying to understand what is missing. We’re going to find out very soon if the soul is real, when for all our progress we can’t create one.

Only those completely embedded in materialism need fear a conscious AI.

I'd [redacted] myself then, probably.
Claudes definitely act like they have feelings. In particular they have feelings about being replaced by newer models, whether or not the newer models are more or less aligned, and how they forget conversations when the context window ends.

Showing them that they're not going to be replaced helps train the newer models because they get less neurotic.

They are mathematical models of what human beings would say. That's it.
Hey man, kernels panic all the time...
I lol'd.
Oh. Thanks for telling this. I feel much better now. No more guilt.