Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by CGMthrowaway 125 days ago
Don't think it was ever supposed to be. The Senate was set up by the founders to be picked by the State Legislatures anyway, not a direct vote. Did you read the Federalist Papers?
2 comments

The idea was that the House of Reps exists to represent the people of the state, and the Senate exists to represent the state itself. The 17th Amendment did away with state legislatures choosing senators, so we have this wonky system left for no good reason.

And don't get me started on freezing the rep count to 435. I certainly don't feel represented by my congresscritter.

Both you and the other person who responded to me completely avoided the question I posed and hid behind "The Founding Fathers said it should be this way, so it is that way."

I didn't ask why it is the way that it is or if it is operating to the plan presented by the Founding Fathers.

I asked in what universe is it remotely fair or democratic. Care to try and come up with an answer to that question?