Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by amanaplanacanal 124 days ago
Plenty of US citizens are in a similar situation: namely those who are in territories that are not US States, like Puerto Rico. Some US nationals are not even US citizens: those from American Samoa carry US passports but are not considered citizens.
3 comments

Citizens of Washington, DC are in the same boat. They can vote for president, but have no representation in congress.
To nitpick: they have a representative, but she's not allowed to vote.
To double nitpick: She's a delegate, not a representative. There are also non-voting members from Puerto Rico, Virgin Islands, Guam, American Samoa, and the Northern Mariana Islands.
Not just them, but undocumented immigrants here pay close to $100 billion a year in taxes.

Immigrants as a broader category here in the US make up around 20% of our total tax revenue.

And also, people like blog author - foreigners with work visa. There are plenty of those, they pay taxes and they dont vote.
Correction though, she's not a foreigner with a work visa, but an EU citizen living in another EU country.
She is still a foreigner. Just because it is relatively seamless to work in another country, it doesn't mean you are a citizen.