Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by behindsight 133 days ago
On a similar vein is the "argument from fallacy" aka fallacist's fallacy. [1]

Essentially if you dismiss someone's argument as false just because it may have had a fallacy within it, that reasoning is itself a fallacy.

Some fallacy-seeking people ironically ignore this and just dismiss anything when they have the "gotcha, you made a fallacy therefore everything you said can be concluded as false" moment.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy

1 comments

You know, I hadn't even been aware that this was a term until now but I've certainly seen it in the wild many times! Thanks for sharing!

The idea that a single fallacy in a complex chain of reasoning renders the entire chain invalid just makes sense to programmers, who spend most of their time thinking in a step-wise and linear fashion where each output is the input to something else. This sort of "programmer style" thinking has crept into some surprising parts of society these days.

In real life, things are often more nuanced.