[bko]

Who is behind this over digitization of primary school? My understanding is that in the Us pretty much all homework and tests are done on computers or iPads.

This obv isn’t a push by parents because I can’t imagine parents I know want their kids in front of a screen all day. At best they’re indifferent. My only guess is the teachers unions that don’t want teachers grading and creating lesson plans and all the other work they used to do.

And since this trend kid scores or performance has not gotten better, so what gives?

Can anyone comment if it’s as bad as this and what’s behind it.

[el_benhameen]

My kids are in elementary school in the SF area (although pretty far in the ‘burbs) and this is not my experience.

The older one has a chromebook and uses it for research and production of larger written projects and presents—the kind of things you’d expect. The younger one doesn’t have any school-supplied device yet.

Both kids have math exercises, language worksheets, short writing exercises, etc., all done on paper. This is the majority of homework.

I’m fine with this system. I wish they’d spend a little more time teaching computer basics (I did a lot of touch typing exercises in the 90’s; my older one doesn’t seem to have those kind of lessons). But in general, there’s not too much homework, there’s good emphasis on reading, and I appreciate that the older one is learning how to plan, research, and create projects using the tool he’ll use to do so in future schooling.

[michaelt]

A few decades ago:

* People needed to be taught digital skills that were in growing demand in the workplace.

* The kids researching things online and word-processing their homework were doing well in class (because only upper-middle-class types could afford home PCs)

* Some trials of digital learning produced good results. Teaching by the world's greatest teachers, exactly the pace every student needs, with continuous feedback and infinite patience.

* Blocking distractions? How hard can that be?

[nine_k]

Reading with AI summaries jumping into your eyes is like writing in a word processor that completes sentences and paragraphs for you.

Writing with a word processor that just helps you type, format, and check spelling is great. Blocking distractions on a general-purpose computer (like a phone or a tablet) is as hard as handing locked-down devices set up for the purpose, and banning personal devices.