[Dylan16807]

> Firstly, dynamic IPs are quickly reused

Define quickly? My modem stays attached on the same IP for months at a time.

> so if one customer get an IP onto a bunch of firewall blocklists

That can happen anyway! Most of those are based on outgoing connections!

> a bunch of other angry customers as well as beg all the firewall vendors to unblock those IPs

Does this happen today on the huge number of ISPs that let you open ports on a dynamic IP? I'm not aware of it.

> we need to keep in mind net neutrality was not written for selfhosters

Well I'm not really focused on the idea of net neutrality, just whether it's reasonable to make customers unconnectable, and I say it's not reasonable.