[xienze]

> I don’t know where the LLMs are picking up this paranoid tendency to handle every single error case.

Think about it, they have to work in a very limited context window. Like, just the immediate file where the change is taking place, essentially. Having broader knowledge of how the application deals with particular errors (catch them here and wrap? Let them bubble up? Catch and log but don't bubble up?) is outside its purview.

I can hear it now, "well just codify those rules in CLAUDE.md." Yeah but there's always edge cases to the edge cases and you're using English, with all the drawbacks that entails.

[gpm]

I have encoded rules against this in CLAUDE.md. Claude routinely ignores those rules until I ask "how can this branch be reached?" and it responds "it can't. So according to <rule> I should crash instead" and goes and does that.