[ggm]

Because they operate in a non good faith model where discouraging voting and gerrymander is normalised. The electoral commission is politicised, not neutral and independent. Because voting is held at times and dates which disadvantage working poor, because voter ID rules are capricious and partisan.

[joe_mamba]

>because voter ID rules are capricious and partisan.

Can you elaborate?

[croon]

When looking at supporters of voter ID laws, look at whether they support free IDs, expansion of DMVs/issuers of IDs, etc.

Similarly, opposition of mail-in-voting typically ignores or supports closing down polling places (in strategically partisan areas), making it difficult for groups of people to vote.

These issues are always (by design) discussed in isolation, while ignoring the intrinsically related issues.

TL;DR: Voter ID laws are fine, only if, coupled with universal free IDs for citizens. And no mail-in-voting would be fine, if voting occured on a national holiday, and polling places were reachable by all eligible voters. This is not supported by any (elected) proponent of voter ID laws or opponent of mail-in-voting.

[iamnothere]

My proposal:

- Free FEC federal voter ID (requires proof of citizenship) to be used ONLY for voting

- Voter ID can be obtained early (age 16?) but DOB is connected to ID and you can’t vote before the legal age

- Funded FEC program to register students for voter IDs at schools and colleges and teach them about voting

- FEC to work with agencies like social security and IRS to determine if a voter is deceased (messy process). Likely deceased voters are communicated to the states ASAP. States must report confirmed deceased voters to FEC ASAP for recording.

- Federal 2 week minimum early voting period

- Federal funding and monitoring of elections requiring adequate polling site coverage of geographic areas, notification of residents, etc

- Federal program to provide free shuttle to and from nearest polling station for residents without transit. Operated federally, states have no involvement. Contract with private transit as FEMA does.

- Mail in ballots heavily restricted, must provide proof of absence or be military

- Voting day is a national holiday

- Federal ballots are separate and simplified to speed up counting/recounting (ballot complexity is often cited as a reason for slow counting)

It will never happen but this would solve so many issues.

[croon]

Yes, which is why no politician who supports stricter voter ID laws or limiting mail-in-voting would support those proposals, because those issues aren't about strengthening democracy/participation but about voter suppression.