Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by qart 142 days ago
> nobody in Canada wants anything to with your 'ethno nationalist wars'

Absurd. These are YOUR 'ethno nationalist wars' because your country has given them a safe haven. This problem does not exist in India. Not one Sikh I know sympathizes with these separatists, and I have plenty of Sikh friends, been to their homes, been to their hometowns.
2 comments
bluegatty 142 days ago
These are literally murders by Indian nationals on other Indian nationals, involving Indian government.

We want nothing to do with this.

Nobody is getting 'safe haven' - we have 'laws' and 'citizenship' so we respect those things, otherwise, we'd prefer all of you who want to continue your infighting to go home. Totally unwelcome.

Crucially - has nothing to do with this post.

link
qart 142 days ago
> These are literally murders by Indian nationals on other Indian nationals

They are all in your immigration pipeline or already through it. The crimes are all on Canadian soil. Who has jurisdiction in the so-called "rules-based international order"?

> involving Indian government

This is your fantasy. You're playing fast and loose with accusations, just like Carney and Trudeau were while calling it "rules-based international order".

> We want nothing to do with this.

Then stop providing asylum. Stop courting them for votes. Prosecute criminals.

> Crucially - has nothing to do with this post.

Refer to the first line that I quoted.

link
bluegatty 140 days ago
"They are all in your immigration pipeline or already through it. The crimes are all on Canadian soil. "

India Logic: "We go somewhere else to commit crimes, it's their fault"

I don't want to say anything too offensive, but this is 'garbage logic'.

On the subject of migration - it's literally the 'garbage logic' that the majority of 'good people' are trying to escape.

Stop trying to defend the indefensible.

link
qart 140 days ago
Canada logic: "Let's take in people who have links to Canadian crime gangs, and when things go bad, let's just blame India"

> it's literally the 'garbage logic' that the majority of 'good people' are trying to escape.

Thank you very much!! Please take more 'good people'! I heard "asylum crackdown began in Canada" by someone else right here. Please go protest it. I suppose these people are all upstanding model citizens of Canada now. You are most welcome to blame the murder of Harpreet Singh Uppal on India too. Just keep taking more 'good people'.

> Stop trying to defend the indefensible.

OK. I will personally accept all future blame, just like Jesus Christ. Only if you promise to keep taking more 'good people'.

link
JumpCrisscross 142 days ago
> This problem does not exist in India. Not one Sikh I know sympathizes with these separatists

Then problem solved! If there are no separatists there is nobody to offer asylum to!

link
qart 142 days ago
It is that simple. Canada is not learning. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/G76aXJOWkAA4CNy?format=jpg&name=...
link
alephnerd 142 days ago
Most of the asylum claims came before CY2025, which is when the false asylum crackdown began in Canada [0].

A major issue was the Truduea-era diplomatic spat that led to the expulsion of Canadian [1] and Indian [2] diplomatic staff who cooperated on background checks along with an MP in Punjab who ran a "cash for asylum claim" racket [3].

After Carney became PM and Anand became MFA, the Canada-India relationship went back on track, and Trudeau era appointees were largely sidelined.

[0] - https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/chandigarh/canada-c...

[1] - https://www.canada.ca/en/global-affairs/news/2024/10/ministe...

[2] - https://www.mea.gov.in/press-releases.htm?dtl/38420/India+ex...

[3] - https://theprint.in/ground-reports/punjabi-illegal-migration...

link