Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by master_crab 155 days ago
The quickest way to kill a revolution in Iran is to air anything from the Shah’s family.

The previous revolt happened for a reason.

4 comments

Upon what are you basing this position?

I’ve spent the past week with someone who was born and raised in Iran and who has close family members still there. Their statements surprised me - according to them, while Iranians as a whole are not supporters of monarchy specifically, the vast majority see the theocracy as intolerable at this point and see Pahlavi as the only viable path forward with enough support to form a working government.

Do they want to live under the Shah? Most likely not, but they would absolutely prefer it to the status quo.

The goal here isn’t to put the Shah in power, but to rely upon him to form a transition government to avoid a power vacuum and then work out what comes next.

I looked this crown prince history up and he’s been a proponent of democracy there for decades, not returning to a monarchy (ironically). So he says but it should be noted
> previous revolt happened for a reason

It also happened over three decades ago.

I’m not saying airing the Pavlavis is a great idea. But I wouldn’t assume it’s negative without evidence.

It was actually over four decades ago.

The Pahlavis still have a negative perception in Iran. Just because they aren’t the Ayatollahs doesn’t mean it’s a good idea to bring them up.

Serious question: do you think people in Iran would prefer the status quo, or Return of the Shah (son)? My gut says Shah, but I don't know anyone from Iran, so that's just a guess.
There is actually polling on this.

About 30% would take the shaw has a first or second choice. This is higher than support for the current regime but the country is deeply divided on what an alternative future would look like.

https://gamaan.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Iranians-Polit...

It’s a serious question but it’s not a relevant one. There isn’t a ballot with just “Pahlavi” and “Ayatollah” on it; and there probably never will be considering how much Iranians hate both.
So do you think most Iranians approve of the present regime? And if not, what do you think they should be doing?