Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by simianwords 149 days ago
Sure but its just people buying things.. so what?
2 comments

Billions of people buying things has unintended negative consequences. Advertising exists to amplify desire to increase buying.

It doesn't take a high intelligence to perceive the problem.

People buy things because it provides them value. Increasing buying means that more value is being delivered to humanity. Advertising makes the world a better place.
Weird thought: if advertising is misleading harassment, perhaps it doesn't even increase consumption overall, but only consumption of the things being advertised. Perhaps people would buy more, from the market as a whole, if left in peace and given impartial advice about products only when they seek it.
you really don't see the problem with what you say? are you trolling?
The problem that I didn't compare the improvement to humanity to the damage to the environment?
You can't argue with a philosophy of death.

Humans must dramatically modify their environment to thrive.

What they want: human modification of the environment to entirely stop.

Human regression is actually what they're after.

the first sentence "People buy things because it provides them value." is very false. that's central to many of the problems with marketing.
How is it "false?" Why would people buy anything otherwise?
Why do your recent comments defend OpenAI so strongly?
I dislike this framing. Criticizing an argument is not defending, and it certainly doesn't mean the critic likes the opposing side of the argument. Seems like you're the one with the bias, having created your account just today for this one specific post.
lol idk what you want to imply but ok
The way you phrased this makes it sound like he's a shill, but his takes about AI don't seem unusually complementary.
I'm specifically defending advertisement here.