[ufo]

How do you handle persistent state in your actions?

For my actions, the part that takes the longest to run is installing all the dependencies from scratch. I'd like to speed that up but I could never figure it out. All the options I could find for caching deps sounded so complicated.

[embedding-shape]

> How do you handle persistent state in your actions?

You shouldn't. Besides caching that is.

> All the options I could find for caching deps sounded so complicated.

In reality, it's fairly simple, as long as you leverage content-hashing. First, take your lock file, compute the sha256sum. Then check if the cache has an artifact with that hash as the ID. If it's found, download and extract, those are your dependencies. If not, you run the installation of the dependencies, then archive the results, with the ID set to the hash.

It really isn't more to it. I'm sure there are helpers/sub-actions/whatever Microsoft calls it, for doing all of this with 1-3 lines or something.

[ufo]

The tricky bit for me was figuring out which cache to use, and how to use and test it locally. Do you use the proprietary github actions stuff? If the installation process inside the actions runner is different from what we use in the developer machines, now we have two sets of scripts and it's harder to test and debug...

[embedding-shape]

> Do you use the proprietary github actions stuff?

If I can avoid it, no. Almost everything I can control is outside of the Microsoft ecosystem. But as a freelancer, I have to deal a bunch with GitHub and Microsoft anyways, so in many of those cases, yes.

Many times, I end up using https://github.com/actions/cache for the clients who already use Actions, and none of that runs in the local machines at all.

Typically I use a single Makefile/Justfile, that sometimes have most of the logic inside of it for running tests and what not, sometimes shell out to "proper" scripts.

But that's disconnected from the required "setup", so Make/Just doesn't actually download dependencies, that's outside of the responsibilities of whatever runs the test.

And also, with a lot of languages, it doesn't matter if you run an extra "npm install" over already existing node_modules/, it'll figure out what's missing/there already, so you could in theory still have "make test" do absolute everything locally, including installing dependencies (if you now wish this), and still do the whole "hash > find cache > extract > continue" thing before running "make test", and it'll skip the dependencies part if it's there already.

[plagiarist]

If you are able to use the large runners, custom images are a recent addition to what Github offers.

https://docs.github.com/en/actions/how-tos/manage-runners/la...

[philipp-gayret]

Depends on the build toolchain but usually you'd hash the dependency file and that hash is your cache key for a folder in which you keep your dependencies. You can also make a Docker image containing all your dependencies but usually downloading and spinning that up will take as long as installing the dependencies.

For caching you use GitHubs own cache action.

[1a527dd5]

You don't.

For things like installing deps, you can use GitHub Actions or several third party runners have their own caching capabilities that are more mature than what GHA offers.