Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ben_w 157 days ago
> Is the law protecting victims or banning depictions?

Both. When there's plausible deniability, it slows down all investigations.

> If you try to do the latter, you'll run head first into the decades long debate that is the obscenity test in the US. The former, meanwhile, is made as a way to make sure people aren't hurt. It's not too dissimilar to freedom of speech vs slander.

There's a world outside the US, a world of various nations which don't care about US legal rulings, and which are various degrees of willing-to-happy to ban US services.

1 comments

>There's a world outside the US

Cool, I'm all for everyone else banning X. But sadly it's a US company subject to US laws.

I'm just explaining why anyone in the US who would take legal action may have trouble without making the above distinction

Definitely a core weakness of the Constitution. One that assumed a lot of good faith in its people.