Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by isodev 164 days ago
> Kind of wild that a private company has that kind of power

Also kind of wild that it’s a private US company pushing their current political views on another sovereign state. Cloudflare as a political tool of leverage is a level of dystopia we really should try not to unlock.

6 comments

What are the exact political views the Cloudflare is pushing here?

That it is unreasonable for Italian soccer rights owners to try to use Cloudflare to enforce their broadcast restrictions with 30 minutes notice?

That it is unreasonable not to have a appeal right for these restrictions?

That the technical solution demanded is technically infeasible?

Not sure that these are political views at all.

They're threatening to take their ball and go home. If they move all of their operations out of Italy, under what principle does Italy demand they block content globally? Should Wikipedia remove their page on Tiananmen Square because the Chinese government demands it (which they would, if they thought it would work)?
The Chinese are smart enough to realize how evil you look if you ask for s.th. like that.
i think it’s quite normal and always have been normal for companies to leave countries when the regulative environment goes against them.
Most of them are not as brazen as putting "change your laws or here is how we will fuck you over" in a tweet.
I can assure you that a lot of Italians agree with Cloudflare on this topic.
I think the parent is trying to say that whatever issues Italy may have internally, it's not up to Cloudflare to comment or enact solutions on their own.

  a private US company pushing their current political views on another sovereign state
This has always been the case in the western world, even before America itself existed. Some use the US govt (CIA) as leverage but often will just do it themselves.
They push nothing, they push back on retarded decision. Italy is not even a real market for them