Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by notorious_pgb 166 days ago
Interesting, but the PRF / LargeBlob extensions already enable just such functionality (and more) without relying on the secrecy of a public key.

Why not just use those?

Edit: that's what I get for not reading far enough -- the article addresses this, though I would quibble with the confident assertion that the extensions are not available in major browsers, given I worked for a startup literal years ago which built major functionality on top of these extensions, which were available in (at least) all relevant mobile browsers.
1 comments
csuwldcat 166 days ago
I addressed this in the post - neither is available across all major browsers: https://backalleycoder.com/posts/passseeds-an-experiment-in-...

Ironically, you could make a pollyfill for the PRF functionality with this.

link
notorious_pgb 166 days ago
Very fair (see my edit), though I would submit to you that this isn't a sufficient polyfill for PRF, since PRF allows for a _secondary secret_ alongside the public key, allowing the server to safely store the public key without storing the cryptographic seed material itself.

The inability to use a passkey for the purposes of both authentication and secret storage (at least, without building non-trivial additional cryptographic plumbing) seems to me a reason to just use and push for the continued adoption and acceleration of the purpose-built extensions, instead of reusing a _public_ key as private material.

link
csuwldcat 166 days ago
Saw your post above - I didn't "assert falsehoods", both are missing major browser support:

https://caniuse.com/mdn-api_credentialscontainer_get_publick...

https://caniuse.com/mdn-api_credentialscontainer_get_publick...

link
notorious_pgb 166 days ago
You're right and I was misremembering (we had only developed against modern mobile browsers), though I am 100% certain we made use of these extensions on iOS Safari, so I honestly don't believe caniuse when they assert that it supports _neither_ extension. Per my recollection, iOS Safari supported the large blob extension quite early on.

Apologies for the brash statement earlier; that was wrong of me.

link