[azinman2]

None of the alternatives seem To have anything close to the radio/recommendation power of Spotify. I don’t know how they ever could - they don’t have the massive data Spotify has in listening history combined with playlists and their descriptions… on top of building world class ML audio analysis models.

I’d love have my own local mp3s get this super power. I just don’t see it happening. Plex has their own attempt but it’s no where close.

[lanfeust6]

Seems redundant to get recommendations from your own mp3s. And "radio" would just be playlists on shuffle.

You can decouple discovery from offline music experience. Outside certain genres that I'm not deep into, there's almost nothing I get rec'd on Spotify that I didn't already know of from other sources.

[xp84]

I agree, I don’t need recommendations from my own library. I know when I am in the mood for a particular album, and if not, it’s much more pleasant to glance through my Artists list than to trust some jerk at Spotify to tell me what I want. Especially since they are now actively trying to replace the music on their mood playlists with royalty-free stock Muzak.

For discovery, there are plenty of (especially linear) streaming music sources that are dirt cheap or free, anyway.

[gf000]

To be honest, it may be my music taste, but the recommendations I get are extremely boring and are just rehashes of my liked songs..

But it may be that I hit a bug quite some times ago where each offline downloaded song got added to the liked songs playlist and even though I manually removed quite a few of those, it may have corrupted my user profile.

[biotinker]

If you scrobble to a service like last.fm you get something approaching this functionality. This is something built into most of these services.