[nateb2022]

Your post, most of your comments here, and much of the source code looks AI generated; I get the feeling you lack sufficient understanding of what you're even trying to achieve here.

Also regarding the code, why are you defining private?

  #define private public

(https://github.com/Dealta-Foundation/DealtaCore/blob/e1598d3...)

This is a massive code smell.

[potsandpans]

I'm sick of every top comment in every front page article being an accusation of ai generation.

[stuartjohnson12]

I'm sick of low quality ai generation in an awful lot of front page articles.

[nateb2022]

As am I.

In the case of commentary, an author who uses AI to converse about "his" work indicates a fundamental misunderstanding/lack of comprehension thereof which leads to

The case of code, where an author who is unqualified to have built a certain product himself is thereby unqualified to review AI generated code implementing said product.

The author's post features the quotation of "Brokers", whose quotation has no logical basis except in established LLM generational norms. Furthermore the excessive colons following each feature are also typical of generated text.

The code is not much better. As I spotted rather quickly, the

  #define private public

is a huge code smell; for those unfamiliar with C++ or OOP it is an equivalent blunder to

  #define true false

or

  #define while if

And points to a pretty large disconnect between the author's ability to prompt a model and their ability to evaluate the quality of the model's response.

[kalenvale]

You are absolutely right! Jokes aside, i got other things to take care of. Regardless of what you believe, the code is not AI generated, vibe coded etc. Is it a quick and dirty? Yes, but from what i remember, it is purely for testing. Bad practice, for sure, no doubt, lots of workarounds. It is OOP after all. Also as i wrote, the code needs polishing, it is an alpha after all. Thanks for the audit!

[fc417fc802]

How does a model even end up outputting that? It goes way beyond code that's a bit buggy or convoluted. If a human did any of the above outside of a humorous context I'd consider it openly malicious.

That said, while I'm no fan of slop I don't feel like the constant accusations of AI we now see bandied about are constructive. The general vibe at this point feels like name calling or even a witch hunt.

Bad or lazy writing should be called out regardless of how it was produced. Same for code. I'd say that "#define private public" stands on its own as case in point; how it was arrived at seems almost entirely irrelevant.