Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by CamperBob2 170 days ago
Still, I'm very curious what happens when people who have just cheated their way through college, or these kinds of professional exams, meet the real world? Will they all get fired a few months down the track?

They will continue to use AI to do their jobs. Eventually, the people who pay their salaries will ask themselves why they continue to pay them.

To wholesale trust the output of AI and remove any human in the loop, well, it needs to be really correct all the time.

It's not now, but it will be. Accounting is what you might call an exact science, one where creativity isn't rewarded and where hallucinations by one model can be detected and corrected by others. There is no need for humans to do this type of work.
2 comments
Qem 169 days ago
> Accounting is what you might call an exact science, one where creativity isn't rewarded

Not sure of this. Corporations pull a lot of creative accounting all the time:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_accounting

link
patrickdavey 169 days ago
well, lets take that as true (no more humans doing accounting). Doesn't that mean that there'll be a knowledge gap there? What happens when new rules come along (laws change all the time which will affect accounting practices). How will an AI (at least the current batch) learn what needs to change when there's no prior art for it to lean on?

I mean sure, if we ever get AGI then all bets are off, but, as far as I know we're not there, and LLMs are unlikely to evolve into AGI. They're not thinking right? It doesn't actually _understand_ anything right? I mean, I'm quite probably wrong here, but, as far as I can tell it's really just very fancy backwards autocomplete.

link
CamperBob2 169 days ago
(Shrug) Thinking, unthinking, meh. If you can perform near the top level at the International Math Olympiad you're not going to have much trouble with the tax code.

What will likely happen is that future tax codes will be written specifically with rules oriented towards automation. We won't have to train general-purpose LLMs by shoving trainloads of IRS documents, Congressional records, and tax court cases at them, as happens now. I think we'll see lots of specialized models ramp up at some point, for efficiency's sake if not just for accuracy and traceability.

link