Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mr_toad 180 days ago
> first sale doctrine) dictates that copyright is exhausted upon the first sale of the device (i.e. to the distributor).

The copyright doesn’t go away when copies are sold to a distributor. Someone (probably the manufacturer) still has legal obligations to the copyright holder.
2 comments
chii 180 days ago
copyright doesn't give you the kind of rights that a GPL license does - which is not based on copyright, but on contract law (ala, it's in the name - licenses).

A sale of an object does not transfer those licenses (but those licenses are still valid on the seller - a manufacturer selling widgets will have to obey the GPL clauses. If an end user of this widget wants the source code, they have to go back all the way to the manufacturer, rather than any of the middle-men presumably).

link
gpm 180 days ago
With regards to further distribution of the copy sold to the distributor, it does go away.
link