Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vlovich123 176 days ago
No, because then no language would be included, including Rust. Implementation bugs are not treated the same as integral parts of the language as defined by the standard. Python is defined as memory safe.
1 comments

I understand this website as focusing on unsafety in a more practical sense of writing your stack in memory safe ways, not in the sense of discussing what's theoretically possible within the language specs. After all, Fil-C is standard compliant, but "run everything under Fil-C" is not the argument it's making. The most common language runtime being memory unsafe is absolutely an applicable argument here, mitigated only by the fact that it's a mature enough runtime that memory issues are vanishingly rare.
Fil-C is super new and while it is memory safe, a lot of work is still ongoing in terms of getting existing programs to run under it and currently it only supports Linux which is nowhere near being “c and C++ can now be memory safe”.