Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lefrenchy 169 days ago
Or it’s inauthentic and people don’t want AI slop that anyone can generate.
2 comments

If it can be generated with a prompt, it has infinite supply and finite demand. It’s literally worthless in all senses of the term.

What worries me is that it’s reducing the value of actual engineering work (or good quality art). It’s like car lemons. Their existence also reduces the value of the good quality work

> It’s literally worthless in all senses of the term.

I think that misunderstands the economics:

For a long time we've been able to generate mathematical solutions at a prompt, and yet those still have value - I still gain by having them. Email is free and ubiquitous, but still has value. Clean water, for example, is generally free and ubiquitous, but has enormous value; I'd die without it.

In the market, things are priced by their marginal value - the added value of the last one sold; your 10,000th glass of water is not as valuable as your 1st (if you have only 1). But price != value: 'price is what you pay, value is what you get'.

Clean water isn’t free? Utility bills increase year on year.
It's very cheap. If buying the next glass of water was life-and-death, how much would you pay? The current price reflects its abundance.
It’s worth it though my manager said I was an extra good little worker in my last review. (/s)
> it’s inauthentic

I have a hard time believing that a population deeply into social media, an ocean of inauthenticity - disinformation, influencers, bots, trolling, etc. - and who actively support people who advertise their inauthenticity with pride (such as certain politicians), suddenly care about authenticity.

They don't want AI messing up the 'authenticity' of their social media? lol

I mean a line was gonna show up at some point. Maybe for a lot of people AI was that line. Or AI pushed too hard too quickly making the line too apparent.
I think it's just fear of change and new things, and authenticity is one rationalization of it.

That said, I care very much about both authenticity and regulating AI.