[bawolff]

> In the case of quantum algorithms in BQP, though, one of those properties is SNR of analog calculations (which is assumed to be infinite). SNR, as a general principle, is known to scale really poorly.

As far as i understand, that isn't an assumption.

The assumption is that the SNR of logical (error-corrected) qubits is near infinite, and that such logical qubits can be constructed from noisey physical qubits.

[pclmulqdq]

There are several properties that separate real quantum computers from the "BQP machine," including decoherence and SNR. Error-correction of qubits is mainly aimed at decoherence, but I'm not sure it really improves SNR of gates on logical qubits. SNR dictates how precisely you can manipulate the signal (these are a sort of weird kind of analog computer), and the QFTs involved in Shor's algorithm need some very precise rotations of qubits. Noise in the operation creates an error in that rotation angle. If your rotation is bad to begin with, I'm not sure the error correction actually helps.

[seanhunter]

> The assumption is that the SNR of logical (error-corrected) qubits is near infinite, and that such logical qubits can be constructed from noisey physical qubits.

This is an argument I've heard before and I don't really understand it[1]. I get that you can make a logical qubit out of physical qubits and build in error correction so the logical qubit has perfect SNR, but surely if (say the number of physical qubits you need to get the nth logical qubit is O(n^2) for example, then the SNR (of the whole system) isn't near infinite it's really bad.

[1] Which may well be because I don't understand quantum mechanics ...

[adgjlsfhk1]

The really important thing is that logical qbit error decreases exponentially with error correction amount. As such, for the ~1000 qbit regime needed for factoring, the amount of error correction ends up being essentially a constant factor (~1000x physical to logical). As long as you can build enough "decent" quality physical qbits and connect them, you can get near perfect logical qbits.

[JanisErdmanis]

Having demonstrated error correction, some incremental improvements can now be made to make it more repeatable and with better characteristics.

The hard problem then remains how to connect those qubits at scale. Using a coaxial cable for each qubit is impractical; some form of multiplexing is needed. This, in turn, causes qubits to decohere while waiting for their control signal.