[petegrif]

Surely the fact that NaCl is currently led by Google should not disqualify it from being a potentially valuable contribution to web apps. Most prevalent technologies started in this way, include js. And most started in a much less 'open' way than NaCl. The point surely is not where they originate but rather whether they offer enough distinctive value that they are compelling enough to be adopted more widely and hence become a key part of our ecosystem. Hence the question is, does NaCl have such a compelling value proposition? Evidently, in Brandan's eyes, and those of several of his colleagues, the answer is no. But other people can disagree and hope that the value is sufficient to eventually win over a broader market share. A good example of such a community is those with large code bases in say C, or C++ who would rather port their code than rewrite it all with all the ensuing maintenance problems. Imho NaCl does have something distinctive to offer and I wish the project well.