Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by konfekt 192 days ago
They may have rendered absurd to not have TLS, but they also rendered certification absurd, in the sense that all you get is little more than encryption: if you care about identity, then the free Let's Encrypt certificate coupled to a domain owner's email address gives you little guarantee. Compare this to the extended validation certificates with personally certified credentials and browsers attesting these by, say, a green address bar (instead of today's flat padlock), that a bank customer expects before entering their login data.

Setting up an encrypted web-domain with continual Let's Encrypt certificate renewal has become tedious cargo-culting around the relicts of the idea of a certificate that establishes trust by identity verification.

The collapse of identity-based certification is not Let’s Encrypt’s fault. People naturally choose the easiest option, and Let’s Encrypt supplied it.

Entrusting a handful of commercial certificate authorities with global identity is dubious on first principles anyway, but at least they tried; yet, for all its flaws, that centralized system has proven more practical than the idealistic, decentralized "web of trust".