Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bc569a80a344f9c 187 days ago
“Just let students vibe code your ERP” is a hell of a take.
3 comments

What do you think the consultants are doing? They're mostly last year's graduates anyway.
Is it any worse than an army of consultants? It would be one thing if it was some off the shelf software but a huge chunk of this project seems to be a new custom application intended for student and faculty use.

It just sounds like Accenture-ware with a new name.

If you’re going to open with “is having cs students hack their way to a solution via AI actually worse than Workday?”, this isn’t a fair discussion for who you’re replying to. I assume you’re young and well-intentioned. I would have said the same thing when I was young. The problem is that approach leaves you with, best case with overworked students looking for glory instead of pay, failing classes and enjoy hacking, ~80% of the work done and no staff for maintenance. This isnt an opportunity for hero hacker story, its a real business, it affect people’s lives at their most vulnerable (higher education, paid education, hospital system)
Admitting "Our students cant design or code" is also pretty wild.