[vanschelven]

When a colleague told my father that "duplication is always bad" he grabbed a random memo from that colleague's desk and said "I bet there's at least 3 copies of this piece of paper in this building". That drove the point home alright.

[esafak]

This is not the riposte you might think it is. Duplication serves a different purpose in print; it lets you avoid having to pass the memo around.

[vanschelven]

I think the riposte is against the word "always" and it worked precisely because one could blindly pick a counter example from the physical space of the discussion.

I.e. it worked because it smashed the broad statement and forced a discussion about particulars. Now who was right about those, I have no idea, since I wasn't even present.

[synecdoche]

How? Why?