Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rich_sasha 196 days ago
I wonder if this would very quickly get politicised.

Because what would you teach in these classes? I guess you'd start with, avoid debt, spend according to your means etc.

Next minute some politician will be concerned voters take it too seriously and start judging them by their ability to stick to budgets. Nononono. Let's make that curriculum less revolutionary.

Then I suppose there's corporate interest too. Surely spending withing your means is un-American? Let's include in the lessons stuff about spreading the cost of your purchase over 3 years on a credit card. And did you know Visa, our educational partner, offers you a student credit card with just 280% annual interest and 0.001% cashback, just to get you to dip your toes in the world of crippling debt? I mean, sustainable personal finance. And if that all gets too much, here's some opioid painkillers. There, much better.

2 comments

We need to stop thinking like this for sure. Good advice is good advice, regardless of where it comes from.

The key lesson kids need to learn is to avoid debt and live within their means. Now-a-days every business has decided there is more revenue in pushing their individual debt platforms rather than their products. Go into the Gap, and the staff is heavily incentivized on pushing "Gap Cards", but not on actual product sales.

I won't get into a religious debate on if all debt is bad, but it is a fact that without financial awareness this is the #1 problem facing households today, spending above their means and having "bad" debt dragging down their wealth building.

At an early age I pointed out to my kids, as we went through a store cashier, the signs about "get a <x> card for savings" and brainwashed them that those are traps. They are now in college, everything is cash flowed, and they will not have a credit card in their name (in fact their credit is locked).

"But how will they be able to afford a house and get a loan if they don't have a credit score?!" -- by saving and investing their money instead of spending it with pieces of plastic. Loans can be given with manual underwriting. Cars can be bought with cash following simple rules.

Aside from all that though, just teaching AWARENESS and intentionality from a personal finance class will carry on beyond the class. Having awareness of spending (i.e. "Can I afford this?"), followed by intentionality ("I'll save $500 for the next three months and then buy it, instead of paying payments. I can wait!"), followed by planning (i.e. budgeting), and you have someone who is going to be successful and build wealth.

They could teach things like how credit cards, car and personal loans, and mortgages work. That the 'monthly payment' is not the only important piece of information. How tax brackets worth, how investments work, what bonds and stocks are. And so on and so on. None of this was taught when I was in high school, yet we're all expected to know these things to navigate life in the modern world.

I suspect ignorance is desired. Financially illiterate people are more profitable.

> I suspect ignorance is desired. Financially illiterate people are more profitable.

Spot on, my friend. This is the only conclusion I've come to after watching my kids go through the school system.