[colechristensen]

I found it pretty funny how bad Claude was at cropping an image. It was a cute little character with some text off to the side on a white background, all very clean cartoon vibes and it COULD NOT just select the character. I pursued it for 20 minutes because I thought it was funny. Of course it was 45 seconds to do it myself.

A lot of my side projects involve UIs and almost all of my problems with getting LLMs to write them for me involve "The UI isn't doing what you say it's doing" and struggling to get A) a reliable way to get it to look at the UI so it can continue its loop and B) getting it to understand what it's looking at well enough to do something about it

[visioninmyblood]

I agree claude and chatgpt and even gemini does a poor job in detecting and cropping into a region. Some of the simplest tasks, Qwen also is great at summerization but not into solving simple vision tasks like cropping, segmentetation and detection. Here is an examples where we compared claude, gemini, chatgpt and other frontier models for simple(and complicated) visual tasks https://chat.vlm.run/showdown#:~:text=Crop%20into%20the%20cl...

[colechristensen]

The part that was funny to me is I would respond "is that right?" and it would tell me exactly how it was wrong and proceed to do it incorrectly again in a very similar but different way. It was like a Monty Python sketch. I might have also been very tired and easily amused.