Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hearsathought 242 days ago
> Have you actually spoken to Tibetan refugees who fled Chinese extermination before you arrived at this crazy world-view ?

"Extermination"? Why lie so egregiously. It just makes you look like an agenda driven clown. To you people does "Crazy world view" mean anything based in reality and facts.

> There were 100,000 of them in India at one point of time.

I've watched videos of tibetans complaining about racism/violence in india. Does that count?

> Still >70k presently.

Wonder why so many left india? How many tibetans are in china? Over 7 million. Have you talked to them? Wonder why 99% of tibetans chose extermination in china to "freedom" in india.

The chinese must be terrible at extermination because the tibetan population grew during the past century.

Edit:

Stop stealth editing your comment.

> India hasn't annexed and exterminated several hundred-thousand native civilians.

You are right. It's in the millions.

> China has.

But not tibetans.

> Will never claim that India is good

But you just tried. "India hasn't annexed and exterminated several hundred-thousand native civilians.".

> but an objective assessor can definitely know who are the bad guys regarding the conquest of Tibet.

I agree. Those objective assessor are called TIBETANS. You know the 99% who chose "extermination" in china over "freedom" in india.

1 comments

> "Extermination"? Why lie so egregiously. It just makes you look like an agenda driven clown. To you people does "Crazy world view" mean anything based in reality and facts.

Agenda-driven clown ? Dear lord, How can you be this ignorant ? That number is actually on the lower scale. The Central Tibetan administration (govt in exile) gave the upper estimate at above one million. You can check several sources - including wikipedia. Hell, there are books written on the subject by several authors. Most third-party estimates at a few hundred thousand, however, if you keep the scope to the invasion and the subsequent crackdowns.

> How many tibetans are in china? Over 7 million. Have you talked to them? Wonder why 99% of tibetans chose extermination in china to "freedom" in india.

Yeah, importing Han Chinese and calling it population of Tibet is 100% nonsense. You are aware, I hope, that the census includes all residents living in TAR - regardless of ethnicity ?

> You are right. It's in the millions.

What are you smoking ? When did Independent India invade and kill millions ?

> I agree. Those objective assessor are called TIBETANS.

You mean the Han Chinese are objective assessors ? Ask a group of people outside of China please.