Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SubiculumCode 199 days ago
I personally don't get what they are serving with a home NAS? Movies/Music/Family Photos is all I can think of, personally...and those don't seem that compelling to me compared to cloud.
5 comments

Any substantial movie/series collection can be more over a TB and thus not cost efficient to host in the cloud.

I've been running a server with multiple TB of storage for many years and have been using an old PC in a full tower case for the purpose. I keep thinking about replacing the hardware, but it just never seems worth the money spent although it'd reduce the power usage.

I have it sharing data mainly via SSHFS and NFS (a bit of SMB for the wife's windows laptop and phone). I run NextCloud and a few *arr services (for downloading Linux ISOs) in docker.

(Currently 45TB in use on my system)

Edit: as no-one is asking, I base my system on mergerfs which was inspired by this excellent site: https://perfectmediaserver.com/02-tech-stack/mergerfs/

> and those don't seem that compelling to me compared to cloud

I tend to be cloud-antagonistic bc I value control more than ease.

Some of that is practical due to living on the Gulf coast where local infra can disappear for a week+ at a time.

Past that, I find that cloud environments have earned some mistrust because internal integrity is at risk from external pressures (shareholders, governments, other bad actors). Safeguarding from that means local storage.

To be fair to my perspective, much of my day job is restoring functionality, lost due to the endless stream of anti-user decisions by corps (and sometimes govs).

Also ebooks and software installers, but those and movies/music are my main categories.

Cloud costs would be... exorbitant. 19 TB and I'm nowhere near done ripping my movies. Dropbox would be $96/month, Backblaze $114/month, and OneDrive won't let me buy that much capacity.

And you can buy those disks for… $300 or $400 apiece, I guess? A onetime purchase.
Another use case is hobby photography. Video storage (e.x. drone footage), or keeping a big pile of RAW photos. The cloud stuff becomes impractical quickly.
I host mine locally to backup the cloud or in case Google just screws my account one day.