Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pjmlp 195 days ago
Kotlin won Android on internal Google politics, zero technical merit.

Feel free to write another long reply on how Kotlin is somehow special, going to replace Java, while the first iteration of Kotlin Native was a failure with a broken design on its reference counting memory approach, and there is still no KVM to replace the JVM in sight, despite such greatness as pointed out in Android circles.

1 comments

I haven't defended Kotlin's approach in any way, I don't know why you want to put words in my mouth.

However if you don't see why Kotlin was well positioned, while Scala was not, then you clearly don't know much about either language.

Technical merit is subjective, but different design decisions can precisely be made to win politics or not, and JetBrains made the right ones, first to convince people internally (who knew about Scala, you know), then Google, as they were fairly well aligned.

I know enough about Google politics, and JVM ecosystem is part of my toolbox since 1996, starting with JDK 1.0.1, I have lived through all hype cycles of JVM guest languages since Beanshell was introduced.