Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cbolton 208 days ago
I'm not too familiar with macOS... How normal/expected is it now to install through the App Store? As mentioned in another comment, for a Linux distribution like Debian there are highly trusted official repositories, and I think using "sideloading" for other sources would make some sense.
1 comments
makeitdouble 207 days ago
On macos I assume most apps are installed outside of the Store, straight from the developper's site. Which would make the Store a "sideloading" channel by that token ?

On Linux you have the default package sources, but for instance adding third party sources will still integrate the same with the system, I also never heard someone call installing Go or Java "side loading", though you're getting an installer from the site you need to run on your own. Same way for building from source.

IMHO "sideloading" would not apply to any system open enough, where adding stuff from multiple sources is expected from the start.

link
cbolton 207 days ago
> Which would make the Store a "sideloading" channel by that token ?

I don't think so, it's still an official channel offered by the OS maker.

> adding third party sources will still integrate the same with the system

but obviously with a higher risk of breakage since it was not tested while the official release was cooking (at least for Debian the official set of packages in stable is expected to have virtually no conflict issues, but as soon as you add third-party sources all bets are off).

> I also never heard someone call installing Go or Java "side loading"

neither have I, but I can imagine that in some contexts it could be a useful term. Like "did you sideload Go?" (implicitly asking if you got the third-party release vs installing from the official distribution repository). I'm not saying people say that, but that the term might also make sense in the Linux world.

> IMHO "sideloading" would not apply to any system open enough, where adding stuff from multiple sources is expected from the start.

Yeah if there's no sense of "main" channels that are more trusted or more stable the term doesn't make sense.

link