Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Crestwave 204 days ago
`#!/usr/bin/env bash` is the most portable form for executing it from $PATH
2 comments
Ferret7446 203 days ago
I raise you a https://www.felesatra.moe/blog/2021/07/03/portable-bash-sheb...

Pedantic, but "#!" and "portable" don't belong in the same sentence

link
Crestwave 192 days ago
The script you posted is only portable in theory and not in practice. Executing it while using a non-POSIX shell like Elvish (even without having it as a default shell) makes it immediately fail.

Meanwhile, `#!/usr/bin/env` is completely portable in the practical sense. Even systems with non-standard paths like NixOS, Termux and GoboLinux patch in support for it specifically.

link
hamandcheese 204 days ago
Is this meaningfully more portable than #!bash though?
link
tombert 204 days ago
In a sibling thread someone pointed out that #!bash doesn't actually work if you're calling it from bash, and appears to only work with zsh.

I just tried it and they were absolutely right, so `#!/usr/bin/env bash` is definitely more portable in that it consistently works.

link
saurik 204 days ago
This mechanism doesn't do a PATH lookup: #!bash would only work if bash was located in your current working directory.
link