Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by AlgebraFox 205 days ago
While censorship is one thing, they forgot another overlooked ability of these app stores: pushing unwanted apps/services to our personal devices without our knowledge.The fact that the majority of people don’t care about this censorship and backdoors makes me think we don’t really appreciate the concept of freedom, and maybe we are okay with being slaves—at least until we cannot take it anymore. Maybe that’s why history repeats itself every few decades to remind us about these values.
1 comments
gruez 205 days ago
>While censorship is one thing, they forgot another overlooked ability of these app stores: pushing unwanted apps/services to our personal devices without our knowledge

When was the last time the play store or app store pushed apps "without our knowledge"? I've only heard of it done by shady third party bloatware that OEMs bundle with the OS. The actual issue is a system that can perform OTA updates, not app stores themselves.

link
AlgebraFox 204 days ago
What about when Google pushed Android Safety Core to all Android devices out there?

And you also realize they can push modified build of any apps, now that they also own the keys to sign the apps?

link
gruez 204 days ago
>What about when Google pushed Android Safety Core to all Android devices out there?

You mean the package that apps have to opt in to use? I guess that's technically counts as "unwanted apps/services", but that's like complaining about firefox "pushing unwanted apps/services", because they added some javascript function to every firefox installation out there.

>And you also realize they can push modified build of any apps, now that they also own the keys to sign the apps?

If you read my original comment more carefully, you'll notice I'm not denying they have the capability to do so, only that there's no precedence of them doing so.

link
realusername 204 days ago
It happened a few months ago with Gemini at least for Android, probably similar for Apple Intelligence on iOS although I can't comment since I don't use it anymore.
link
knollimar 205 days ago
The play store doesn't even update my apps for me anymore often
link
pjc50 204 days ago
There was the time Apple dropped a U2 album on everyone, to widespread annoyance, but that's not the same thing.
link