Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jesse__ 228 days ago
> It's not network requests that are a problem. It's nondeterministic network requests.

Ohhhhh, right, my bad. I forgot that you could just make network requests deterministic with the __do_it_determinstically flag. Of courseeee, how could I be so silly.

..

Think about it; you just illustrated my point exactly. If the network request is assumed to always complete, with the desired payload,, and the client/server exist on the same machine, then why the fuck is there a network request?? An LSP server is just a library, but instead of being loaded into the process address space like a normal library, there's a separate server for some unknown reason.

Anyways, /rant
2 comments
skybrian 228 days ago
A local network connection is the lowest-common-denominator way to do foreign function calls. This allows the language server to be written in any language you like without having to deal with the complexity of linking code written in different languages together. It just starts another process and connects to it.

For example, VS Code is written in TypeScript and the Go language server is written in Go.

link
ChadNauseam 228 days ago
Do the client and server necessarily exist on the same machine? I thought vscode had an architecture where the frontend and backend could be on separate machines, although I don't know if the LSP crosses that gap.

Also, I'm sure there's a way to do it, but if someone wanted to write an LSP in Haskell and the editor was written in JavaScript, I'm not sure it would be as straightforward to load it as a dynamic library as you suggest it should be.

link
jesse__ 228 days ago
Theoretically, the client/server don't have to be on the same machine, but in practice they mostly are.

As for the interface.. any language that can't speak the C ABI isn't a real language (read: they all can).. but this is besides the point.

Counterpoint; when's the last time you used an editor written in JavaScript and an LSP written in Haskell? I bet never.

link
skybrian 228 days ago
If you install the VSCode plugin for Haskell, I’m pretty sure that’s what you get?
link
jesse__ 227 days ago
It's funny that I forgot people actually use VSCode .. I think of it as a bad joke.

Fair point though.

link
tome 227 days ago
I think VSCode is written in TypeScript, but yes, I found counterpoint very strange too!
link