Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by feisty0630 220 days ago
It's not "dumb", you're just presenting a steelman that directly contradicts what the person you're replying to wrote.

You might indeed be shocked to find that not everyone consumes fast food.

2 comments

What strikes me about this exchange is no one is talking about the money. In the past, you could do either and no one had to care except you. Now a lot of jobs that people could find fulfilling aren't because the economy is so distorted, so how are we supposed to honestly look at this? I guess let's walk these people off the plank and get this over with...
Did the people who worked on the farm to grow and harvest your food enjoy it?
Are you seriously and earnestly arguing that harm-minimisation is useless and we should all just open the human-suffering throttle, or did you just not think that far ahead?

I am hoping the latter. Being foolish is far more temporary a condition than being cruel.

Increasing productivity is how we minimize harm. Many people hate their job but are happy to have it because it allows them to consume things. More production = less suffering
How are you “minimizing harm” by pearl clutching about not eating fast food? The front line people you are interacting with at the fast food restaurant or the grocery store have it easiest in the chain of events that it takes food to get to you. Do you think that fast food workers have it harder than the people at the grocery store?
0.8*harm < 0.81*harm - hope this helps!

Also, the core point is about people being able to find meaning in their work. That you've decided to laser in on this specific point to go on a tangent of whattaboutism is largely irrelevant.

Have a nice day.

The fact is that most of the 3-4 billion+ people on earth don’t “find meaning in their work” and they only work because they haven’t overcome their addiction to food and shelter. If the point was irrelevant to your argument, why make it?
I didn't actually make the point initially. I was challenging the reply's point that:

a) just because some people are miserable at work, doesn't mean we shouldn't care that other people might become miserable at work

b) Someone saying they prefer their food to be made without suffering is clearly a hypocrite in all cases because... there are miserable people in fast food jobs?

I mean... really. Come on now.